Pennsylvania 2-10-0 "Decapod" Type Locomotives

Class Details by Steve Llanso

Class I1s Type A (Locobase 5153)

William D. Edson (Keystone Steam & Electric, 1974) adds that these engines also had "[a] Belpaire boiler, [mechanical] stoker, Worthington feedwater heater, power reverse gear, heat-treated steel reciprocating parts, and underhung crossheads." Of the five sets of drivers, only the first and last had flanges, which reduced the design's minimum curve radius. See Locobase 32 for a comment on the unique design of Pennsy's Belpaire firebox.

Pennsy built the first 123 at their Juniata shops in 1916 and 1918-1919. Never very stylish, these were brute-force engines serving wherever there was a long train and a steep grade.

Alco Estimating Engineer James Partington (in "Avoidable Waste in Locomotive Operation as Affected by Design", Railway Age, Volume 95, No. 11 (5 November 1921), pp. 673-677) comments that the secret to the I-1's great success lay in setting the proportions to allow for limited cutoff operation. Continuous high tractive effort levels on the long uphill runs were achieved by using a long stroke and large cylinders, but cutting off the steam at 50% of the stroke rather than the more usual 90%. Limiting the cutoff may allowed the railroad to use 12" (305 mm) piston valves.

"The expected increase in economy of coal and water," Partington observed, "...has been fully realized. Not only has the engine shown remarkable efficiency, but the economy under wide ranges of load is especially remarkable [sic]."

As a reminder of what "efficiency" consisted of in the steam era, note that the I-1 achieved a maximum of 8.1% thermal efficiency (generating 1,777 ihp), and averaged over 7%. Maximum IHP came to 3,080 (at 40% cutoff and 2.9 lb of coal per IHP hour.).

See Locobase 15291 for the 475 Baldwins of 1922-1923, which introduced

Class I1s Type E - 1922 (Locobase 15921)

Data from DeGolyer, Vol 68, pp. 388+ . Works numbers were:

1922

November 55725-55730, 55777-55785

December 55817-55855, 55943, 55945

1923

January 55946-55989, 56069-56076

March 56164-56194

April 56410-56415, 56432-56452

May 56489-56502, 56531-56535, 56546-56565, 56615-56629

June 56643-56682

July 56747-56758, 56776-56803

August 56869-56895, 56945-56967

September 57037-57061, 57100-57104, 57125-57170

October 57229-57231, 57272-57317

William D. Edson (1974) recorded that these engines also had "[a] Belpaire firebox, Worthington feed water heater, [mechanical] stoker, power reverse gear, heat-treated steel reciprocating parts, and underhung crossheads." Of the five sets of drivers, only the first and last had flanges, which reduced the design's minimum curve radius. A combustion chamber measuring 42.25" added 90 sq ft (8.35 sq m), which together with the 31 sq ft (2.9 sq m) of fire brick tubes, completed the supplementary direct heating surface. Also, the Pennsy had adopted an unusually "square" tube and flue arrangement (usually engines of that era fitted with Type E superheaters had many more flues than tubes). See Locobase 32 for a comment on the unique design of Pennsy's Belpaire firebox..

As Locobase 67 relates, tests on the I-1s in 1923 led to changes in the boiler.

Class I1s Type E - 1929 (Locobase 67)

Data from table in 1930 Locomotive Cyclopedia and PRR Steam Locomotive Diagrams supplied in May 2005 by Allen Stanley from his extensive collection. See also "Tests of A Class I 1s Freight Locomotive Equipped with a Feed Water Heater and Type E Superheater", Locomotive Testing Plant Bulletin No. 32 (1924).

Baldwin delivered these 475 decapods in 1922-1923; see Locobase 15921

Of the five sets of drivers, only the first and last had flanges, which reduced the design's minimum curve radius. See Locobase 32 for a comment on the unique design of Pennsy's Belpaire firebox.

The dimensions shown in the specifications come from the Pennsylvania's diagrams, which were dated from the late 1920s. The changes apparently resulted from the Pennsylvania's tests of an I-1s in February 1923. Engineer of Tests F M Waring stated that the "substitution of the Type E for the Type A superheater and the resultant large increase in heating surface has not noticeably increased the evaporative capacity or efficiency of the boiler." He concludes that the evaporative heating surface area in this design limited any possible gains regardless of the size of the superheater.

Waring also noted that use of the Worthington feed water heater resulted in a 14% savings in coal use.

Although no recommendations for modifications to the I-1's boiler appear in the report and the Belpaire firebox remained unchanged., differences found in diagrams prepared just a few years later suggest that the Pennsy's motive power heads decided to adjust the balance of the tube-flue area. Given the Waring's conclusion regarding the boiler's EHS, it's odd that both tube and flue counts both dropped, but the boiler lost more than twice as many 3 1/2" flues than 2 1/4" tubes. Also, tube and flues were all trimmed by 6".

In fact, both the M-1 4-8-2 and the I-1 2-10-0 used boilers with many more small tubes than were found in most boilers with Type E superheaters.


Specifications by Steve Llanso
Class I1s Type A I1s Type E - 1922 I1s Type E - 1929
Locobase ID 5153 15921 67
Railroad Pennsylvania (PRR) Pennsylvania (PRR) Pennsylvania (PRR)
Country USA USA USA
Whyte 2-10-0 2-10-0 2-10-0
Road Numbers
Gauge Std Std Std
Builder several Baldwin several
Year 1916 1922 1929
Valve Gear Walschaert Walschaert Walschaert
Locomotive Length and Weight
Driver Wheelbase 22.67' 22.67' 22.67'
Engine Wheelbase 32.17' 32.17' 32.17'
Ratio of driving wheelbase to overall engine wheebase 0.70 0.70 0.70
Overall Wheelbase (engine & tender) 73.04' 73.04' 73.37'
Axle Loading (Maximum Weight per Axle) 72600 lbs
Weight on Drivers 334500 lbs 334500 lbs 352500 lbs
Engine Weight 366500 lbs 366500 lbs 386100 lbs
Tender Light Weight 182000 lbs 182000 lbs 204700 lbs
Total Engine and Tender Weight 548500 lbs 548500 lbs 590800 lbs
Tender Water Capacity 9000 gals 9000 gals 10300 gals
Tender Fuel Capacity (oil/coal) 17.5 tons 17.5 tons 18.7 tons
Minimum weight of rail (calculated) on which locomotive could run 112 lb/yard 112 lb/yard 118 lb/yard
Geometry Relating to Tractive Effort
Driver Diameter 62" 62" 62"
Boiler Pressure 250 psi 250 psi 250 psi
Cylinders (dia x stroke) 30.5" x 32" 30.5" x 32" 30.5" x 32"
Tractive Effort 102027 lbs 102027 lbs 102027 lbs
Factor of Adhesion (Weight on Drivers/Tractive Effort) 3.28 3.28 3.45
Heating Ability
Firebox Area 272 sq. ft 312 sq. ft 322 sq. ft
Grate Area 70 sq. ft 69.90 sq. ft 69.90 sq. ft
Evaporative Heating Surface 4315 sq. ft 4818 sq. ft 4590 sq. ft
Superheating Surface 1360 sq. ft 1986 sq. ft 1634 sq. ft
Combined Heating Surface 5675 sq. ft 6804 sq. ft 6224 sq. ft
Evaporative Heating Surface/Cylinder Volume 159.46 178.05 169.62
Computations Relating to Power Output (More Information)
Robert LeMassena's Power Computation 17500 17475 17475
Same as above plus superheater percentage 21700 22543 22019
Same as above but substitute firebox area for grate area 84320 100620 101430
Power L1 17103 23153 19958
Power MT 563.61 762.98 624.11

Photos

Reference

  • PRR Steam Roster - N E Rails
  • The Unofficial Pennsylvania Railroad Home Page
  • A Pennsylvania Railroad Home Page
  • PRR Documents
  • Pennsylvania Railroad Technical & Historical Society
  • Attlerburg's Engines - 1, Great Increases in Horsepower and Speed by Bert Pennypacker in "Trains" October 1979, issue page 22 - 32
  • Attlerburg's Engines - 2, She could get on her knees and work drag tonnage, 72 inch drivers not withstanding by Bert Pennypacker in Trains November 1979, issue page 44 - 49
  • Pennsy Power II: Steam, Diesel and Electric Locomotives of the Pennsylvania Railroad by Alvin F. Staufer and Bert Pennypacker (Alvin F. Staufer)
  • Pennsy Power: Steam and Electric Locomotives of the Pennsylvania Railroad, 1900 - 1957 by Alvin F. Staufer (Alvin F. Staufer)
  • The Pennsylvania Railroad - 1940s - 1950s by Don Ball, Jr (Elm Tree Books, Inc)
  • The Search for Steam by Joe G. Collias (Heimburger House Publishing Co.)

Credits

Introduction and roster provided by Richard Duley . Class details and specifications provided by Steve Llanso of Sweat House Media.

{link-v-xlrg-1}

privacy policy